Algeria, 50 years on: No commemoration here

If a ceasefire ending a bloody conflict is signed, but neither of the once-warring parties formally commemorates the event 50 years later, did the history actually happen?


The Algerian War is one of those historical episodes that everyone seems to talk about in France – but only in a way that skims the historical surface.


Schoolroom platitudes about a painful conflict are drummed into every French student.


But the conflict is rarely explained in a getting-to-the-bottom-of-things way.


The French media has done a valiant effort trying to fill in some blanks this week.


A stream of documentaries has accompanied the half-century anniversary since the signing in 1962 of the so-called Evian Accords between France, and Algeria’s triumphant independence fighters, grouped under the banner of the National Liberation Front (FLN).


The pact ended nearly eight years of war in which French historians state that at least 400,000 people were killed (however Algerian historians put that figure at 1.5 million), on both sides.


More broadly, it capped 132 years of French colonial rule in Algeria dating back to 1830.


But for all the fanfare, neither France nor Algeria has chosen to mark the anniversary with a nationwide commemoration.


A humiliating French defeat


In France, the official reason offered for the absence of a national observance is to avoid “fanning the flames” of a bitterly disputed historical episode.


In Algeria, meanwhile, President Abdelaziz Bouteflika apparently wants to avoid exploiting the anniversary in a way that might antagonise a French partner that accounts for one-fifth of Algeria’s external trade (double the business Algeria does with China).


Unofficially, the Algerian War is fraught with humiliation - and shame - for the French.


The ceasefire may have ended the fighting, but it did not halt the atrocities perpetrated by the French or their minions.


Within days of the Evian Accords, a shadowy group of French fighters known as the Organisation of the Secret Army (OAS), fiercely opposed to Algerian independence, turned its wrath against fighters and ordinary citizens.


The OAS has been blamed for acts of armed insurrection, collective massacres and targeted assassinations. (Jean-Paul Sartre was said to have narrowly escaped an attempt on his life). There have been questions as to whether candidate Sarkozy would decide to honour veterans of the group, which is regarded as a patriotic front by many French.


The continuing fallout of the Algerian war has insinuated itself into France’s bitter election battle in other ways as well.


It has galvanised forces on the right of the political spectrum that Nicolas Sarkozy is mindful of alienating at a critical political moment.


From one calamity to another


While the 1962 ceasefire was a coda to conflict, it was also a curtain-raiser to further suffering and upheaval for hundreds of thousands of European-descended Algerians, known as “pieds noirs”.


For these people, the end of one calamity, in many cases, signalled the beginning of a new one: repatriation, loss and a new life in an unfamiliar “homeland” whose citizens had little understanding, or empathy, for their plight.


Then there were the so-called Harkis, as many as 200,000 Algerians and other Muslims from across North Africa, who fought with French troops during the war.


They often faced brutal reprisals after the war, coupled with a cold shoulder (or worse) from the French “compatriots” with whom they went to battle.


Sarkozy recently spoke of their “abandonment” and suffering – saying they were forced to choose between “the suitcase and the coffin”.


An independence fight usurped


The war remains an open sore in Algerian society as well.


Many Algerians feel that the independence struggle was usurped by military officials interested only in shoring up their own power at the expense of revolutionary ideals.


As French Weekly Courrier International put it, in a special issue on the Algerian War anniversary, revolution gave way to dictatorship as presidents were installed in power merely as a way of lending a veneer of democratic legitimacy to the new regime.


Algerians prefer to celebrate July 5th – the date of their proclamation of independence – rather than March 19, when the ceasefire went into effect.


For young Algerians, meanwhile, the war and its martyrs is a fast-receding historical marker.


The decrepit state of the economy, the lack of job opportunities, and a brake on social mobility are far more pressing concerns for the new generation.


They perceive their leaders as corrupt usurpers of the ideals bequeathed by the independence struggle.


As for Algeria’s independence fighters, they are emblems of a courageous, bygone era.


As an article appearing today in El Watan points out, many young people in Algeria draw a blank at the mention of March 19, 1962.


They are at pains to name a single negotiator at the Evian Accords.


“I feel respect for these men,” one young person told the newspaper. “I am ashamed to say it, but all this history doesn’t interest me. I recognise that they did remarkable things, but none of this should be exploited in the name of goodwill.”

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of FRANCE 24. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. FRANCE 24 is not liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.
Ukraine and the EU: Ukraine the Victims of the Soviets & Now the Victim of organized crime. After the Second World War, we would expect that the Participation of Germany in the World Stage would be more of active role in preserving the peace and world order. It is to me alarming that the Chancellor of Germany - Angela Dorothea Merkel, as well as the European Central Government’s, in exchange for fast cheap energy would rather allowed a bullied Dictator like Vladimir Putin, violated International laws, invaded Ukraine, killed Innocents Ukrainians and with a gang of Russians organized thugs divided an European Nation, which had cried for help to the west. Vladimir Putin, who is disguising himself as an Elected President, will stop at NO sanctions or any threats. Because reviewing the past of Vladimir Putin is to see the Present element which he is the same THUG of Saint Petersburg, Russian of the 1990s. It is not a secret that Vladimir Putin, has been in Jailed for criminal acts and was just another Soviet officer with serious emotional and Psychological impotence. It is Sad that Germany Chancellor of Germany - Angela Dorothea Merkel, do not take a leadership roll in imposing more serious and defining sanctions against her Friend Vladimir Putin. It is Sad that the USA and Nato as of today have failed to protect Ukraine territorial integrities. The Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances is a political agreement signed in Budapest, Hungary on 5 December 1994, providing security assurances by its signatories relating to Ukraine's accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. The Memorandum was originally signed by three nuclear powers, the Russian Federation, the United States of America, and the United Kingdom. China and France gave somewhat weaker individual assurances in separate documents.[1] The memorandum included security assurances against threats or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine as well as those of Belarus and Kazakhstan. As a result Ukraine gave up the world's third largest nuclear weapons stockpile between 1994 and 1996.[2][3] Following the 2014 Crimean crisis, the U.S.,[4][5] Canada[6] and the U.K.[7] all separately stated that Russian involvement is in breach of its obligations to Ukraine under the Budapest Memorandum, and in clear violation of Ukrainian sovereignty and territorial integrity. I asked myself, Is 30% of Germany dependency on Russian energy worth more than the lives of those that had died and the thousands of lives of those that will be lost in Ukraine by the Vladimir Putin Regime? Chancellor of Germany - Angela Dorothea Merkel, silence is equivalence to the death of over 600's if not thousands of Ukrainians... The European Union, is the Sole responsible for all of those deaths in the unstoppable civil war in Ukraine. Because the European Union TOY, play and was never serious on helping and integrating Ukraine in to a Modern and Western European Nations. The full responsibilities of all atrocities in Ukraine, falls under the cradle of The European Union. There are many solutions that can be implemented to resolve these crises. One of which is to send real peace Keeper from the United Nation, the E.U. And the USA. The Civilized world, need to displayed now to the frustrated dictator Vladimir Putin, that we will not allow him to play with the new world order and that Russia is solemnly an energy producing economy with a few Nuclear war head that can just go off right where they are now stored. Ukraine needs immediate military support as Ukrainians are tired of EU and the World vague sympathy’s... Vladimir Putin is nothing more than a common gangster ruling a country of hard working and honorable Russians…. The Russian Army, will never fight a war of lies. The Russian Army, will never last more than six months in battle against professional soldiers. It is just my Opinion Ray Baez
After being kicked out of Algeria in 1960, why would rcnafe let any of these glorified swine into La Belle Pays? Where is the logic? Someone please help me understand! I only hope the current cohort of 15-30 will have the balls to stand up and defend France before it's too late.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.